Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
A. Background of the Study
Trains are considered one of the fastest
modes of transportation in the Philippines. Compared to taking the bus, taking
the train is more convenient especially when you’re in a rush. Although being
elbowed and jolted is common since most people prefer this, and most people are
always on a rush, and mostly don’t have a choice, it is guaranteed that taking
the train can save you more time.
It is also one of the most popular among
commuters due to the fact that it can take 560,000 passengers daily from north
to south, and vise versa, in half an hour, according to an article entitled
“Messed-up Transport System” by Tita Valderama.
Valderama wrote, “The MRT and LRT lines offer rapid
transport of passengers from one end to the other. But you cannot expect
convenience at the same time, particularly during the morning and early evening
rush hours”
(http://www.manilatimes.net/messed-up-mass-transport-system/74431/).
Although it is a fact that public
transportation causes of air pollution, it is not that main reason for it. It
actually is one big of a help in reducing the pollution of the already polluted
air that we are used to breathing. More vehicles means more pollution, so that
explains that.
The article “Taking the Bus (vs) Compared to
Driving a Car” by The Girls says that Carbon
Dioxide from bus emits 89g of CO2 per
km while a typical car emits 133g per km (.625 mile). As a result, the average
car emits fifty percent (50%) more CO2 per mile than the bus. The Girls
states that a huge automobile population, even when ready with the most
up-to-date emissions control, is a main source of air pollution. It would add
expansively to CO2 emissions,
generally considered to be a major cause of global warming.
The Girls wrote, “Between your
commuting time from destination A to B, your mood and mental health have
possibly improved and you probably formulated a better answer to your problem.” (http://thegirls.hubpages.com/hub/Gas-vs-Bus).
In spite of all the benefits public transportation can offer,
the fact that it can relentlessly harm a commuter’s life is reality. Not only
can it have physical effects, but also have a negative impact on one’s health,
relationships, and mental and emotional stability.
The biggest effects of long
commutes to work tend to be personal relationships, stress-related health
issues, and work performance. Each person reacts differently when being pulled
down. But as studies show, most people react negatively to this. Having to
commute everyday makes you feel like nothing's ever worth it. It makes things
pointless because you're not satisfied, which leads to crap work.
Many commuters deal with these problems as if it’s something
that is permanent and unfixable. However, having enough knowledge about how
public transportation negatively affects one’s life will help commuters balance
their commuting and personal lives.
This paper focuses on how commuting affects us, and what we
can do to compensate.
B.
Statement of the Problem
This study aims to answer the question:
In
what ways can commuting affect us, and what can we do to compensate?
C.
Significance of the Study
Students.
Most students would
benefit from this study because public transportation is not only a part of
their daily routine but also is a factor that affects their performance in
school.
Drivers.
Without them, public
transportation wouldn’t exist. This study will not only help them value road
safety, but mostly understand deeper the reason behind every passenger’s
behavior.
Regular
Commuters. This
research paper would be able to help everyone who takes public transportation
of all ages, especially those who take it on a daily basis. Moreover, the
researcher hopes that pointing out how commuting affects one’s life would help
in finding the perfect balance between personal and commuting life.
Future
Researchers. This
study is essential for researchers to make similar studies since there still
seems to be a lack of information with regards to the issue.
D.
Scope and Delimitation
This study focuses on how commuting affects us, and what we
can do to compensate.
Due to lack of time and information, this study will no
longer discuss how commuting affects the way people interact with other people
but rather focus on how it affects oneself. This is for the benefit of one to
help and understand him/herself better.
E.
Materials and Methods
Information applicable to the study was gathered from a
mixture of reference materials such as books and articles from online
resources.
Descriptive research was also used in this study in order to
have a deeper understanding towards the effects of commuting in one’s life.
F.
Definition of Terms
1.
Anxiety - a
feeling of worry, nervousness, or unease, typically about an imminent event or
something with an uncertain outcome.
2. Emission -
the production and discharge of something, especially gas or radiation.
3. Jolted
– to push
or shake (someone or something) abruptly and roughly.
4. Procrastination -
the action of delaying or postponing something.
CHAPTER 2
DISCUSSION
In what ways can commuting affect us, and what can we do to compensate?
I.
Public
Transportation in the Philippines
Choosing to commute over driving a car is
beneficial in a way that it can help reduce air pollution. Also, taking the
train is considered one of the fastest ways to transport here in the
Philippines. It is far more convenient than taking the bus especially to those
who are in a hurry. It does not only save mother earth, but also time.
In an article entitled “Messed-up Transport
System”, Tita Valderama mentioned that the MRT can acquire 560,000 passengers
daily from north to south, and vise versa, in half an hour.
“The MRT and LRT lines offer rapid transport of
passengers from one end to the other. But you cannot expect convenience at the
same time, particularly during the morning and early evening rush hours”, says Valderama
(http://www.manilatimes.net/messed-up-mass-transport-system/74431/).
When you choose to ride the train, you’re
forcing yourself inside with half a million other strangers, so the worst
should be anticipated. Look forward to being packed liked sardines, and expect
not only physical but also emotional and mental wounds.
According to a research
by Thomas James Christian of Brown University, it is not the total
length of workday that really matters, it is commuting. It is commuting that
makes us lonely. It is commuting that causes the stress. It is commuting that
makes us eat less healthy.
"Longer commutes are
also associated with an increased likelihood of non-grocery food purchases and
substitution into lower intensity exercise activitie." said Thomas James
Christian (http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1490117).
II.
How Commuting Affects
Oneself
Long commutes do not only
give you time to appreciate the beauty of life but mostly give you time to
realize a lot of things such as how your life sucks at the moment. Or the fact
that you could have been pursuing your dreams but instead, you're tip-toed
inside a train, trying not to lose your balance (and temper). It gives you time
to think and over-think things.
According to this article
entitled, "10 Things Your Commute Does To Your Body", author Carolyn
Kylstra stated that commuting during rush hour can result in temporary spikes
in stress levels that jack up your blood pressure, even if it's normally
stable.
"A study of 4,297 Texans found that the farther the participants lived from where they worked- the longer their commutes- the higher their blood pressure was", said Kylstra (http://time.com/9912/10-things-your-commute-does-to-your-body/).
"A study of 4,297 Texans found that the farther the participants lived from where they worked- the longer their commutes- the higher their blood pressure was", said Kylstra (http://time.com/9912/10-things-your-commute-does-to-your-body/).
Commuting
really is the problem, and not the people. Commuting is the perpetrator here,
and the commuters are the victims, so there really is no reason for me to hate
on these people. This all goes to show that these things, sometimes, couldn't
be avoided. And the only way to at least lessen the stress of being packed like
sardines is to just calm down, and be kind. Because you're not the only victim
here. There are 260,000 other people sharing the same feelings and discomforts
as you.
Might as well
try to make the most out of your trip; it's easier, and it's for the best. Who
knows, that guy you just bumped into might end up being the one you'd be
spending the rest of your life with. Again, smoking could lead to lung cancer,
but not all smokers get the disease. There are a lot of nice people in the
world, what better way to find them than being one, right? Stop focusing on the
negatives and try to see things in a different way.
In an
article entitled, "It's Official: Commuting To Work Makes You
Miserable", where author Matt Chorley stated that, well, commuting to work
makes you miserable! The title says it all, but Chorley also said that
commuters have lower life satisfaction and lower levels of happiness, and are
most likely to suffer from higher levels of anxiety. This, I guess, explains
all the crankiness and stuff.
"In
general, all commuters are less satisfied with life, have a lower sense that
their daily activities are worthwhile, are less happy, and have higher anxiety
than those who don't commute.", said Chorley (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2557564/Its-official-Commuting-work-makes-miserable-spending-half-hour-bus-worst-way-travel.html).
A.
Relationships
Marital dissatisfaction is
determined by many things that are far more important. You could be in the
exact situation but that doesn't mean that that's the only reason for your
falling marriage. Smoking can cause lung cancer, but that doesn't mean that all
smokers get the disease.
In an article entitled,
"Your Commute
Can Improve Your Relationship",
author Robert S. Wyer stated that couples who travel in the same direction are
more positive about each other than those who don't.
"People who commuted in
the same direction as their husbands or wives were happier with their
relationships than people who didn't. We think that's because moving in a
similar direction symbolizes the pursuit of similar goal.", said Wyer. (http://hbr.org/2012/11/your-commute-can-improve-your-relationship/ar/1).
When your commute is
shorter, it gives you less time for travel and more for family. And time is the
glue that holds relationships together. Long commutes take away time- that is
lost forever, for our loved ones. So if you were asked to choose between a job
that's farther but pays higher and a job that's nearer but pays lower, think
hard about the trade-off between money and time for your family. You might find
it hard to let the opportunity go, but you will always regret the time with
your loved ones that slipped away.
According
to this article, "Could A Shorter Commute Save Your Relationship?",
author Dharmesh Shah explained that shorter commutes could actually help in
improving or basically maintaining your relationship.
"Long
commutes are stressful, especially when heavy traffic and frequent delays are
involved. It's hard for anyone to walk in the door happy when they've done
everything but play bumper cars on the freeway for an hour.", said Shah
(https://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/20131002171552-658789-could-a-shorter-commute-save-your-marriage).
B.
Health
There's nothing wrong with being fat.
You might look a few pounds heavier than you should and I'd still treat you
like a normal person. What's wrong is being unhealthy, and long commutes cause
unhealthiness.
In an article by Malcolm Farr, it is explained that advertising
influences the type of food we eat and that overseas studies have found that
unhealthy foods are most likely to appear in these advertisements.
“This being the case,
advertising is likely to have played a role in the current obesity epidemic...
Furthermore, targeted advertising of unhealthy foods may entrench and even
increase existing socio-economic inequalities in the prevalence of obesity.” says Farr
(http://www.news.com.au/finance/work/how-suburban-commuters-are-coaxed-into-unhealthy-eating-habits/story-fnkgbb6w-1227089160388).
So, ads don't only make you fat, they
also keep you from having a healthy lifestyle. They have the power to keep
those who are already overweight overweight for the rest of their lives.
Advertisements play a big role in our community. They make people want
something they don't need in the first place, and promise them the good things
without mentioning the bad things.
It is stressful to think of the long day
ahead, but working out in the morning conditions your body and helps you
relieve stress before the day even starts. Don't get discouraged once you hit
the snooze button a few times, because once you get the workout you planned for
that day, it won't matter! A few minutes of moving around is always better than
none.
In the
article entitled "How to Keep a Long
Commute from Wrecking Your Healthy Habits", Jillian Leo recommends morning
workouts because it does not only energize you for the long day ahead, but
also guarantees you to fit it into your day.
"Even though sometimes I feel like crying when my alarm goes off at
4:45 AM, I always feel so much better after a workout. Exercising in the
morning will give you the energy you need to get through the day. " she
adds (http://www.sparkpeople.com/blog/blog.asp?post=how_to_keep_a_long_commute_from_wrecking_your_healthy_habits).
C.
Performance
at Work/School
The biggest effects of long commutes to work tend to be personal
relationships, stress-related health issues, and work performance.
Although
there are a countless number of good things about being a commuter, there are
also challenges that come from having that extra time away from school. In
the article entitled, "Being a Commuter: Pros and Cons"
by La Vie, it was explained that being away from college life sometimes makes
getting into the homework mind harder than it should.
"I’ve realized with the amount of stuff I have going on
there are times when I don’t do the homework as well as I know I could. You
also don’t always have the luxury and time to meet up with your professors if
you do have a homework question." says La Vie (http://www2.lvc.edu/lavie/2012/04/30/being-a-commuter-pros-and-cons/).
In a study by
the Office for National Statistics looking
at commuting and personal well-being, commuters are more likely to be anxious,
and feel that their daily activities lack meaning than those who don’t have to
travel to work even if they are paid more. They also found out that each
additional minute of commuting makes you feel slighting worse.
"Those making long bus journeys to work of more than 30 minutes
had lower life satisfaction, a lower sense that daily activities are worthwhile,
lower happiness levels and higher anxiety;" the ONS says
(http://office%20for%20national%20statistics%20looking%20at%20commuting%20and%20personal%20wellbeing./).
According to the article "Effects of Long
Commutes to Work" by Jeff
Durham, a long hour of commuting is associated with increase in blood pressure,
increased anger and resentment at work, and tardiness.
"Many companies are installing gyms or handing out free gym
memberships which have been popular with those who face stiffness after a long
commute to work and a quick workout not only reduces that but also stimulates
and refreshes the brain as well as the body."
says Durham (http://www.safeworkers.co.uk/effectsoflongcommutestowork.html).
In the same article, Durham mentioned that although many companies have
begun to realize the damage that long commutes can do to their employees and
have become more open to accepting more flexible working patterns which allows
them to work from home now and again, or even completely, for some jobs,
there's no escaping the long commutes.
III.
Conclusion
Based on the data gathered, the researcher concludes that
long commutes can, in fact, negatively affect a person. Not only does it change
the way once interacts with other people, but mostly the way he/she deal with
his/her daily life. In some cases, long commutes trigger one’s unhealthiness,
be it physically, work, or relationship-wise.
Also, these disadvantages are mostly acquired by those
commute regularly; it also depends on the length of your commute, as well as
the route you are taking. It is sad but true, that most Filipinos don’t really
have a choice but to take public transportation which is why these effects are
not very uncommon.
But it doesn’t just end there. Although some might think
that these can actually ruin somebody’s life- which is mostly true- these can
also be a way of testing our ability to solve problems. Of course, it cannot be
avoided, so there must be a solution. Actually, there are a lot of solutions.
If we could just try, then we would be able to balance our commuting and
personal lives.
CHAPTER
III
Summary
This
paper attempts to find out how commuting affects us, and what we can do to
compensate. This study will finish off on what a commuter can do in order to
improve or maintain their personal lives in spite of the effects of long
commutes.
Observational
research method was used in this paper in which the data from all the articles
and documents gathered online were used to answer the questions that are
posted. The research findings are the following:
1.
A long hour of commuting is associated with increase in blood
pressure, increased anger and resentment at work, and tardiness.
2.
Commuting during rush hour can result in temporary spikes in
stress levels that jack up your blood pressure, even if it's normally stable.
3.
Road advertisements influence the type of food commuters eat
and overseas studies have found that unhealthy foods are most likely to appear
in these advertisements.
4.
Each additional minute of commuting makes commuters feel
slighting worse.
Conclusion
Based on the findings of this study, the following
conclusions are drawn:
1.
Commuters are more likely to be anxious, and feel that their
daily activities lack meaning than those who don’t have to travel to work even
if they are paid more.
2.
Commuters
have lower life satisfaction and lower levels of happiness, and are most likely
to suffer from higher levels of anxiety.
3.
Long
commutes can cause obesity, and other eating disorders.
4.
Couples who travel in the same direction are more positive
about each other than those who don't.
Recommendations
After drawing the conclusion of the study, the researcher
hereby make the following recommendations:
1.
Morning workouts should be considered because it does not
only energize you for the long day ahead, but also guarantees you to fit
it into your day. This will not only exercise your physical body, but also your
mind.
2.
When in a relationship where both parties are commuters, the other may have to take a job closer to home, especially if
they have kids. Say, the male takes a job with a long commute, it limits his
partner's job scenario to a minor geographic area which may mean she has a less
fulfilling career and is forced to think an even bigger role in raising the
kids and taking care of the home.
3. When given a choice, think hard about the exchange between time and money (or job title or whatever the bait is.) If nothing else, think of it this way: There’s a great chance you might regret the opportunity that slipped away, but you will always be sorry for the time with your loved ones that was gone.
3. When given a choice, think hard about the exchange between time and money (or job title or whatever the bait is.) If nothing else, think of it this way: There’s a great chance you might regret the opportunity that slipped away, but you will always be sorry for the time with your loved ones that was gone.
References
A. Electronic Media
Chorley, Matt (2014) It's Official: Commuting To Work Makes You Miserable Retrieved on: October 20, 2014 from http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2557564/Its-official-Commuting-work-makes-miserable-spending-half-hour-bus-worst-way-travel.html.
Christian, Thomas James (2009) Opportunity Costs Surrounding Exercise and Dietary Behaviors: Quantifying Trade-offs Between Commuting Time and Health-Related Activities. Retrieved on: October 2, 2014 from http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=10117.
Durham, Jeff (2014) Effects of Long Commutes to Work Retrieved on: November 1, 2014 from http://www.safeworkers.co.uk/effectsoflongcommutestowork.html.
La
Vie (2012) Being a Commuter: Pros and
Cons Retrieved on: November 3, 2014 from http://www2.lvc.edu/lavie/2012/04/30/being-a-commuter-pros-and-cons/.
Leo,
Jillian (2014) How to Keep a Long Commute from Wrecking Your Healthy Habits Retrieved
on: November 3, 2014 from http://www.sparkpeople.com/blog/blog.asp?post=how_to_keep_a_long_commute_from_wrecking_your_healthy_habits.
Shah,
Dharmesh (2010) Could A Shorter Commute
Save Your Relationship? Retrieved on: October 16, 2014 from https://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/20131002171552-658789-could-a-shorter-commute-save-your-marriage.
Wyer,
Robert S. (2012) Your Commute Can Improve Your Relationship Retrieved on:
October 16, 2014 from http://hbr.org/2012/11/your-commute-can-improve-your-relationship/ar/1.